Alexander
All recipes
easy⏱ 5 Min

Alexander

Ordinary Drink · 4 ingredients
Recipe details
Alexander
Ordinary Drink4 ingredients5 steps5 min
Cuisine:
American
Glass:
Cocktail glass
Method:
Shaken
Garnish:
Grated nutmeg
Rate this recipe

Ingredients

1 ozGin
1 ozWhite crème de cacao
1 ozLight creamFrom your kitchen
NutmegFrom your kitchen

Method

1Add gin, white crème de cacao and light cream to a shaker.
2Fill the shaker with ice.
3Shake well until chilled.
4Strain into a chilled cocktail glass.
5Grate fresh nutmeg over the top.

Watch how it’s made

Recipe and photo: TheCocktailDB

The Alexander is a creamy, shaken cocktail built on gin, white crème de cacao and light cream, served up in a chilled cocktail glass with grated nutmeg on top. It tastes soft and lightly chocolatey, with gin keeping it from turning sweet and flat. CBC Liquors, Westford stocks gin for it, and this page covers why the drink works, how to shake it well and what to do when you want a different version.

Why does an Alexander taste so smooth?

An Alexander is smooth because cream rounds off the gin while the crème de cacao adds sweetness and a gentle chocolate note. Each of the three ingredients is used in the same amount, so none of them takes over the glass.

The gin supplies the dry, botanical backbone. Without it, cream and cacao liqueur would taste like a dessert drink. The white crème de cacao is clear, so it sweetens and flavours the drink without darkening it. The light cream gives body and a silky texture, and shaking it with ice makes it slightly frothy.

The grated nutmeg on top is not decoration only. Its warm, sweet-spicy smell reaches you before the first sip and ties the cream and cacao together.

Where does the Alexander cocktail come from?

The Alexander is generally said to come from New York in the early 1900s, with a date of around 1915 often given. As the story is commonly told, a bartender named Troy Alexander made it at Rector's, a well-known restaurant in the city, for a dinner event.

The original used gin. A version made with brandy in place of the gin, the Brandy Alexander, took over in later decades and is the one many people now picture when they hear the name. Plenty of older cocktail books list both, so the gin version on this page is the earlier of the two.

How do you make an Alexander cocktail well?

To make an Alexander well, shake the gin, white crème de cacao and light cream hard with plenty of ice until the shaker is frosty, then strain into a chilled cocktail glass.

Chill the glass first, in the freezer or with ice water while you shake, because a cream drink goes dull quickly when it warms. Use fresh, cold cream and a full shaker of ice so the drink is properly chilled and diluted. A short, lazy shake leaves it thick and heavy.

Strain it straight into the glass with no ice, and finish by grating fresh nutmeg over the top. Whole nutmeg grated at the last moment smells far better than pre-ground. Common mistakes are using cream that is past its best, skipping the chilled glass and over-grating the nutmeg until it overpowers the drink.

What are the common twists on an Alexander?

The best-known twist on the Alexander is the Brandy Alexander, which swaps the gin for brandy and gives a rounder, warmer drink. Everything else in the recipe stays the same.

Another twist is to use dark crème de cacao instead of white. It gives a deeper chocolate flavour and a tan colour in the glass. Some people also use heavy cream for a richer, thicker drink, or shake with a little less cream for a lighter one.

Each of these is a change to the recipe on this page, not the recipe itself. Make the standard version once first, then change one thing at a time so you can tell what each swap does.

How do you make an Alexander for a crowd?

To serve an Alexander to a group, mix the gin and white crème de cacao ahead in a bottle or pitcher, keep it in the fridge, and add the cream and ice only when you shake each round.

Cream does not hold up well in a premixed pitcher left to sit, because it can separate and the drink loses its texture. Keeping the spirits and the cream apart until serving avoids that. Scale the spirits up by keeping the same balance between the gin and the cacao liqueur, and keep the cream cold in its own container.

Shake a few servings at a time with a full shaker of ice rather than one huge batch, so each drink is properly chilled and diluted. Chill the glasses before guests arrive, and grate the nutmeg fresh for each one.

Can you make an Alexander without alcohol?

Yes, you can make an alcohol-free Alexander drink from ordinary kitchen ingredients: shake cold light cream with a little chocolate syrup and a splash of strong, cooled black tea, then strain it into a chilled glass and grate nutmeg on top.

The tea stands in for the dry bite that gin gives the original, and the chocolate syrup replaces the crème de cacao. Taste as you go and adjust the sweetness, since syrups vary. It will not taste like the real drink, but it keeps the same creamy, nutmeg-topped character and looks right in a cocktail glass.

What do you need to buy for an Alexander in Westford?

For an Alexander you need gin, white crème de cacao, light cream and a nutmeg, and CBC Liquors, Westford has gin in stock now, with brands including YU, Irvines and Short Cross on the gin shelf.

The store has no white crème de cacao at the moment. The Liqueur category on the CBC Liquors website shows what liqueurs are in stock, so check there before you plan the drink.

The light cream and the whole nutmeg come from your own kitchen or a grocery run. Add the gin to your order from this page, and bring the cream home cold so it is ready when you shake.

Powered by
esplanda