Godfather
All recipes
easy⏱ 2 Min

Godfather

Ordinary Drink · 2 ingredients
Recipe details
Godfather
Ordinary Drink2 ingredients4 steps2 min
Cuisine:
American
Glass:
Old-fashioned glass
Method:
Built in the glass
Rate this recipe

Ingredients

1½ ozScotch whisky
¾ ozAmaretto

Method

1Fill an old-fashioned glass with ice cubes
2Pour the Scotch into the glass
3Pour the amaretto into the glass
4Stir gently to combine
Recipe and photo: TheCocktailDB

The Godfather is a two-ingredient cocktail of Scotch whisky and amaretto, stirred over ice in an old-fashioned glass. It tastes of malt and almond, warming and gently sweet. CBC Liquors, Westford stocks Scotch and amaretto for it, and this page covers why it works, how to make it well, and what to pick up.

Why does a Godfather taste so good with just two ingredients?

A Godfather works because the amaretto softens the Scotch and the Scotch keeps the amaretto from turning sugary. Amaretto is an almond-flavoured liqueur with a marzipan sweetness and a faint bitterness at the finish. Scotch brings malt, oak and sometimes smoke, which give that sweetness something to push against.

The ice matters too. As it melts, it slowly opens the drink up and takes the edge off both ingredients, so the last sip is gentler than the first. There is no citrus or bitters to hide behind, so the choice of Scotch shapes the whole drink.

Where does the Godfather cocktail come from?

The Godfather is commonly said to date from the 1970s and to take its name from the 1972 film The Godfather. The story most often told is that the actor Marlon Brando liked to drink Scotch with amaretto, and the pairing took his character's name.

The exact origin is hard to pin down, and bartenders have told it in slightly different ways. What is not disputed is that it became a classic of the simple, two-ingredient kind, and it has been the base for several later variations.

How do you make a Godfather properly?

Build the Godfather straight in the glass: fill an old-fashioned glass with ice, pour in the Scotch, add the amaretto, and stir gently to combine. The measures are shown beside the steps on this page.

Use plenty of ice and cubes that are fairly large, because small, wet ice melts fast and leaves the drink thin. Stir just long enough to blend the two liquids and chill them; hard stirring only waters it down. The recipe has no garnish, so the drink is served as it is. Taste it before you change the balance: if it is too sweet for you, reach for a Scotch with more character rather than less amaretto.

What are the common twists on a Godfather?

The most common twist on the Godfather is swapping the base spirit. Each of these is a change to the recipe above, not part of it.

With vodka in place of Scotch, the drink is usually called a Godmother, and it tastes lighter and more almond-forward. With brandy or cognac, it is often called a French Connection. A bourbon version is sweeter and rounder, with vanilla notes from the oak. Some people add a twist of orange peel for a little citrus aroma, or a splash of cream to make it dessert-like. A smoky Scotch is another twist worth trying, since smoke and almond make a surprisingly good match.

How do you make a Godfather for a crowd?

To serve a Godfather to a group, mix the Scotch and amaretto in a pitcher in the same proportions as the recipe, without ice, and keep it in the fridge until guests arrive. Add a little water to the pitcher to stand in for the dilution that stirring over ice would give.

You can mix it a few hours ahead, since there is no fresh juice or fizz to go flat. When it is time to serve, pour it over fresh ice in each old-fashioned glass instead of leaving ice in the pitcher, which would keep melting and thin out the whole batch. Give the pitcher a quick stir before each pour.

Can you make a Godfather without alcohol?

Yes, you can make an alcohol-free drink in the spirit of a Godfather from ordinary kitchen ingredients. Brew a strong black tea, let it cool completely, and pour it over ice in an old-fashioned glass. Sweeten it with a little almond syrup or a drop of almond extract with honey or sugar stirred in, and finish with a squeeze of orange.

The tea gives the tannin and dryness that Scotch usually brings, and the almond stands in for the amaretto. It is not the same drink, but it has the same warm, nutty character. CBC Liquors also has a non-alcoholic category if you want a ready-made alternative.

What do you need to buy to make a Godfather?

For a Godfather you need two bottles, and CBC Liquors in Westford has both in stock: a bottle from the Scotch shelf and a bottle from the Liqueur shelf. The page shows the products available, so you can add them to your order.

For Scotch, the shelf includes Ardbeg, Speyburn and Lagavulin. Ardbeg and Lagavulin are known for smoke, which makes a bolder Godfather; a lighter Scotch gives a softer one. For amaretto, you can choose from CAFFO, DI AMORE and Disaronno. The only other thing you need is ice, which comes from your own kitchen. You can pick up in store, and CBC Liquors also offers pickup, delivery and shipping.

Powered by
esplanda